Mark Harris

Pirate DVDs on sales in Beijing
The 50p DVD is here, but only if you don't mind funding terrorists, gangsters and paedophiles. DVD Review reveals the true cost of pirate DVDs…

It's hard to resist a bargain. Who wouldn't be interested in a copy of the latest DVD (or even cinema) movie at a fraction of its usual cost? With multi-disc releases like the Two Towers now topping £30 for a single film, even those with deep pockets might be tempted to risk a few quid on a 'promo' copy at a car boot sale. But don't fool yourself. These bargains are almost always pirate copies, churned out in the tens of thousands by Far East factories and smuggled into Britain by criminal gangs.

As the format explodes into the mass market, the market for counterfeit DVDs grows apace. By the end of 2003, over 1.5 million pirate DVDs had been seized by Customs or the police: a staggering 400% increase over the previous year. These kind of number make the big studios nervous, says Julie Sneddon, Managing Director of Buena Vista Home Entertainment: "DVD piracy is currently running at around 20% of all copies sold, that's about double the level of VHS piracy at its worst."

Jim Angell, Director of Operations at the piracy watchdog FACT (Federation Against Copyright Theft) fears that these figures are just the tip of the iceberg: "It's hard to say how much we're catching, but if we're getting a third of what's coming in, that would be great." The main sources of pirated DVDs are illegal factories in Asia, from where they're air- or sea-freighted into Europe, or even smuggled in by drug-style mules on tourist flights.

"This is no cottage industry," says Angell, "These gangs are highly organised. If a film is released on a Wednesday here, it'll be back in the UK as a DVD by the weekend. Just four days after a film is shown anywhere in the world, we'll start to make seizures of the title here."

Pressing Matters
The machinery needed to duplicate discs and print labels and covers is widely available and has plummeted in price over the last few years - costs are now down to about 30p per disc. With some street traders here selling counterfeit discs for up to £10 each, the profits speak for themselves. FACT tracked the finances of just one UK trader and discovered deposits of £280,000 in a single month - money that soon disappeared in a wire transfer to the Far East. While these kind of profits rival the money to be made in drug smuggling, the punishments handed out for copyright crimes are rarely more than a slap on the wrist.

This combination of high profit and low risk has attracted the attention of organised criminals, and worse. The Intellectual Property Crime section of the FBI website claims, "There is strong evidence that organised criminal groups in the US have moved into IP (Intellectual Property) crime and that they are using the profits generated from these crimes to facilitate other illegal activities." But Tony Soprano shouldn't get too comfortable, as British gangsters are close behind. The Chinese Snakeheads Triad group has been implicated in the distribution of thousands of fake Harry Potter DVDs across the UK and FACT recently seized a quarter of a million DVDs from a single North London safe house. They also have evidence that some dealers in pirate DVDs also traffic in pornography and paedophilia.

Perhaps even more worrying is the connection between copyright crimes and terrorist groups. The Police Service of Northern Ireland seizes more counterfeit goods than all the other UK police forces combined. Their latest Threat Assessment Report states that nearly half the organised crime groups known to them are associated with, or controlled by, Loyalist or Republican paramilitary organisations. A newspaper report last year went further, alleging that renegade Republicans were directly targeting police and anti-piracy enforcers at a Belfast market with a powerful car bomb.

Jim Angell can't dismiss the terrorist links. "We know that a lot of the money been raised here goes back to Asia, and there is certainly some organisation in Pakistan. Everyone assumes there are links to Al-Qa'ida, but we've no evidence for that at the moment." One problem is that prosecuting modern pirates is no longer as simple as having them walk the plank. Complex IP cases can involve many different agencies (trading standards, Customs and police, here and abroad) assembling a mass of evidence over a long period of time. And although the maximum prison sentence for counterfeiting has recently increased from two to ten years, UK courts have yet to serve up more than four year's porridge for even the worst offenders.

High Tech Detectives
But if law enforcement has yet to take piracy seriously, no one could accuse the film industry of similar complacency. In an effort to cut down on the source of the problem, cinemas now carry copyright warnings before blockbuster movies and a few paranoid movie houses even have staff wandering the aisles with night vision equipment, looking for people using video equipment. In the future, projection equipment may incorporate Dolby's CamJam system, an optical security device that varies the light level in a way that's imperceptible to humans but that can confuse consumer camcorders.

Home piracy is on the increase, too. Peer-to-peer file sharing systems on the internet trade thousands of movie files alongside illegal audio MP3s. But there is one major difference between CD and DVD piracy - the sheer size of DVD files. Converting DVD to even the best quality DivX or MPEG-4 files creates footage that is pixellated, grainy and jerky, usually accompanied by a tinny, stereo soundtrack. Even with a broadband connection, it can take five hours or more to download the 650Mb of data a typical film requires.

Home pirates with a DVD burner can also copy discs on their desktop, using software such as DVD Copy X. Some versions of this package can even copy extras, subtitles and surround sound audio tracks. But with DVD Copy X sporting anti-piracy features (you can only make a single back-up of each movie) and the copy process taking hours each time, it's unlikely to ever take off in a big way.

For all their paranoia about dishonest consumers, it seems that most studios should look closer to home. A recent AT&T study in the USA revealed that over three quarters of the movies being illegally traded over the Web actually came from industry insiders, with a meagre 5% of films appearing after their DVD release. Modern digital editing techniques enable production staff to run off copies of movies at a much earlier stage than was previously possible.

They look like DVDs, they (sometimes) play like DVDs but how do these 50p DVDs we recently picked up in China compare to the real thing?
Click for info on The Matrix Reloaded pirate DVD Click for info on Kill Bill vol 1 pirate DVD Click for info on The Hulk pirate DVD Click for info on Lord Of The Rings Two Towers pirate DVD Click for info on Pirates of the Caribbean pirate DVD

Oscar Wild
Another source of pirate movies has been the preview discs that studios send out to publicise their films. In a bizarre move this autumn, the big Hollywood studios threatened to halt the mailing of screeners to members of the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, who decide the Oscar awards, citing piracy concerns. Independent film-makers saw this as a way of muscling them out of the annual industry back-slap, and a compromise was reached with watermarked VHS tapes replacing plush DVD box sets. Julie Sneddon confirms that anti-piracy measures currently have a very high priority at Buena Vista. "We're tackling the entire supply chain, from the studio in Hollywood, through theatrical release to distribution and retail. We're tightening up all round." Part of this effort involves new anti-piracy technology.

Disney DVD packaging already incorporates dual-film holograms but now it's going one step further with pioneering AEGIS (Anti-Counterfeit Encrypted Graphic Imaging System) holograms on the disc itself. These are a series of sparkling dots that can form pictures, such as the Buena Vista castle, around the inside ring of DVDs. Sneddon continues; "We're working with Customs & Excise, giving them manuals and posters of the new holograms so that they know what to look for when they seize suspect products."

Although he applauds these movies, Jim Angell doesn't foresee technological advances ever stamping out piracy for good. "There are continual developments in copy protection but the counterfeiters always seem to be one jump ahead," he says. "It's impossible to stop the copying and it's impossible to intercept all the smuggled goods. The truth is that some consumers know they're buying counterfeit discs and they don't care."

He sees the industry's biggest challenge in the future not so much in copy protection or even enforcement, but in stemming the demand for pirated goods in the first place. "The cinema ads are part of the process of educating public, both about the penalties for taping movies and also about money trail behind the criminal trade in discs. This trade affects jobs all the way down the line, from film-makers and cinemas to legitimate shops and magazines." FACT estimates that piracy costs the UK film industry over £400 million a year. Putting that in real terms, that's 13 Love Actuallys, 80 28 Days Laters or a frankly terrifying 160 Full Montys every year.

And it doesn't end there, says Angell. "When you factor in everyone employed in making, distributing, marketing and selling the discs, each pirate DVD means a loss of around £40 to £50 per disc to the economy. The Government alone is losing 17.5% of each legitimate sale in VAT." So the next time you have to wait six months for a new kidney, you can blame the under-funded NHS waiting lists on your local DVD pirate…

Worlwide Wait
One way of making pirate DVDs less attractive is to eliminate the staggered release dates that has some territories waiting six months or more after a US premiere to see a blockbuster. The Matrix Revolutions opened simultaneously in 107 countries around the world in an attempt to undermine the demand for pirated DVD. Any suspicions that this was merely an attempt to maximise box office figures before anyone realised how dire it was, are blown out of the water by Buena Vista's similar tactics with Pirates Of The Caribbean.

Julie Sneddon tells us, "We're taking global release dates very seriously. The Pirates of the Caribbean UK premiere was within days of its release in the US, and the UK DVD actually came out a day ahead of the American disc. We're aiming to get worldwide markets much closer in synch."

So perhaps this isn't all a story of gloom and doom. Thanks to illegal factories in Asia and international criminal gangs, law-abiding film fans in the UK are getting to see the biggest movies and DVDs months earlier than previously. Now if the studios can just do something about those £30 releases, they might just sink the pirates once and for all…

Pirates Of The Pacific
Pirates of the Pacific According to HM Customs, 94% of the pirate DVDs imported into the UK come from Asia, with Pakistan, Malaysia and China being the main culprits. And if you think piracy is bad here, in China it accounts for over 90% of DVD sales, with dozens of large scale illegal production lines in the country running off millions of discs every month.

America recently dispatched Commerce Secretary Don Evans to tackle Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao on the issue of piracy. Evans presented the Chinese leader with a copy Intolerable Cruelty that he'd bought for $1 (about 60p - just like a Yank to drive prices up), although it's not reported whether Wen thought the Coens had sacrificed their quirky style in a hunt for box office success.

Walk down any shopping street in Beijing or Shanghai and you'll be approached by dozens of eager locals offering the latest DVDs for little more than the loose change in your pocket. Hawkers stake out tube stations with a selection of the biggest titles, often right under the noses of Chinese police.

If there does happen to be one of the very rare (but very well publicised) crackdowns, the market just moves indoors. Virtually every restaurant and bar with an English menu has a house DVD dealer who'll happily rack out hundreds of titles for you to choose from. And we're not just talking about the blockbusters here. They've got a bigger range than your local WH Smiths; everything from Kurosawa to Kubrick via Disney and French New Wave. It's little surprise, then, that many Western tourists in Asia are passing up ethnic souvenirs and fake Gucci handbags in favour of bringing home a rucksack full of fake discs.

Scam Ahoy!
Not all pirates wear eye-patches and peg-legs… although you should always be suspicious of anyone requesting payment in doubloons. Here's the DVD Review guide to spotting counterfeit discs:

Certification - By law, most DVDs must display a BBFC certificate (from Uc to R18) on both the packaging and the disc. There are a few exempt titles (such as documentaries and music videos) that don't require certification, so check before accusing your local HMV of sailing under the Jolly Roger.

Region coding - Virtually all the genuine DVDs on sale in the UK are coded Region 2 only. If a major Hollywood movie says All Regions or Region 0 on the packaging, there's a chance it's a counterfeit.

Spelling - Watch out for Asian characters or spelling mistakes on the cover. QT is unlikely to have let his little known brother 'Quentim' direct Kill Bill and we can't recall the bit in Star Wars Episode II when 'two men gradually give birth to the feeling white'.

Check the disc - Here's one for the techies. Examine any DVD, paying attention to the area around the central hole (you might have to turn it upside down). As well as various codes and numbers, legitimate DVDs will have the letters 'IFPI' in tiny print. Pirate discs will either have nothing or just a few numbers.

If you're feeling civic minded, you can keelhaul DVD pirates by reporting them to FACT ( Your personal details will remain confidential.

  Return to work page